Safe, reliable, and compliant background checks are essential for any business. In the UK, there is often considerable confusion and uncertainty surrounding the process of conducting background checks.
This misunderstanding is particularly common among employers, landlords, and even job applicants. Whether you’re trying to understand your rights, letting out a property, or hiring a new employee, it’s important to separate fact from fiction.
To help you make more informed decisions, here are some of the most common misconceptions about employment screening in the UK.
11 Common Employment Screening Misconceptions
Misconception 1: All Background Checks Are Similar
One of the biggest misconceptions is that all background checks are the same, but this is simply not true. In reality, every background check differs in its depth, scope, and the type of information it covers. The requirements vary depending on the nature of the job.
For instance, a financial institution may need a comprehensive check that includes verification of professional qualifications and a review of credit history. In contrast, a basic criminal record check may be sufficient for a voluntary role. It’s important for each organisation to understand the realities of background screening to ensure they are protecting their business effectively.
Misconception 2: Only Criminal Records Are Checked
It is a common myth that background checks in the UK always include a review of an individual’s criminal history. In truth, this depends entirely on the nature of the role. For positions involving vulnerable adults or children, a more thorough check is essential to ensure full verification.
These checks may also confirm whether an individual is legally permitted to live and work in the UK. The Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) offers checks at various levels—basic, standard, and enhanced—depending on the role’s requirements. One of the biggest misconceptions about UK vetting is that only criminal records are reviewed, when in fact, background screening can cover much more.
Misconception 3: You Can Perform Any Check Without Consent
Data privacy laws in the UK are stringent. Obtaining consent before conducting a background check is essential, and both organisations and employees must be mindful of this requirement.
Consent is particularly important for DBS applications. Carrying out a background check without informing the individual beforehand can breach the UK’s GDPR regulations and may lead to significant legal consequences.
Misconception 4: A Spent Conviction Will Always Show Up
Depending on the severity of the offence and the sentence handed down, many convictions become “spent” after a certain period. For most jobs, a Basic Disclosure will only show unspent convictions.
Generally, spent convictions remain private unless the role involves sensitive responsibilities, such as working with children, in which case they may be disclosed through a Standard or Enhanced DBS check. This misconception is one of the biggest myths in UK screening.
Misconception 5: Self-Employed Individuals Are Exempt from Background Checks
Even if you are self-employed, you may still be required to undergo a background check, especially if you work in a regulated sector such as social work, healthcare, or education.
Clients or organisations commissioning your services may request a Basic or Enhanced DBS check as part of their due diligence. It is advisable for self-employed individuals to use a reputable background check provider to ensure their records are clear and up to date.
Misconception 6: Background Checks Report Can’t Be Claimed
If you believe your DBS certificate contains inaccurate information, you have the right to challenge the results. The DBS offers a formal process for disputing any errors or omissions on the certificate.
Additionally, individuals can submit a Subject Access Request to find out what information is held about them. This is a right afforded to everyone who wishes to ensure that the information held is fair and accurate.
Misconception 7: Employees Get Disqualified on a Failed Check
A failed background check does not automatically mean you will lose your job. Each case should be assessed individually by the organisation, taking into account the nature of the offence, when it occurred, and its relevance to the role.
Many employers follow policies that promote fair employment practices and support rehabilitation, in line with UK legislation and initiatives.
Misconception 8: DBS Verifications Are Prompt
Background checks, especially DBS checks, can take time to complete.
Depending on the response time of police forces, Standard and Enhanced checks may take anywhere from one to four weeks—or sometimes longer—while Basic checks are often completed within a few working days.
Employers should plan accordingly to avoid delays in recruitment, as there is no guarantee of an “instant” DBS process.
Misconception 9: Background Check Is Only Applicable in Large Companies
It’s a common myth that background checks are only necessary for large companies or highly regulated industries.
While sectors like healthcare and finance do require thorough screening, the truth is that every organisation should carry out background checks. Conducting these checks helps ensure a reliable and safe workforce.
Regardless of whether a business is large or small, poor hiring decisions can have significant consequences, making background checks essential for all. This is one of the key truths about background screening.
Misconception 10: Background Checks Are Always Expensive and Invasive
Background checks are often perceived as costly and invasive, but this is a misconception. The cost varies depending on the type of check and the information required. There is software available that can automate much of the process, making background checks more cost-effective. They are not always expensive, and this is one of the common misconceptions surrounding vetting in the UK.
Misconception 11: Everything Can Be Revealed Through Search Engines
Background checks are often seen as costly and invasive, but this is a common misconception. The cost varies depending on the type of check and the information needed. With the help of automated software, the process can be streamlined, making background checks more affordable. They are not always expensive, which dispels one of the frequent myths about vetting in the UK.
The Last Word On Background Checks
In conclusion, it’s clear that background checks in the UK are often misunderstood. Not every role requires a criminal record check, and the types of checks can vary widely depending on the position and industry.
Background screening is not just for large organisations; it’s an important step for businesses of all sizes to ensure a safe and trustworthy workforce.
Understanding these facts helps employers make informed decisions and dispels common myths surrounding the vetting process.
Ready to ensure a safe and reliable workforce?
Partner with a trusted background check company that offers comprehensive and efficient services. Whether you need local screening or an international background check service, we’ve got you covered.
Get in touch today to learn how we can support your hiring process with confidence and compliance.
